Telling a longtime executive their role is changing. Confronting a partner about performance. Explaining layoffs to a team that trusted you. These are the moments CEOs lose sleep over, and the ones they are most tempted to delay.
Delay rarely helps. Problems grow, rumors fill the silence and the conversation gets harder. The good news is that difficult conversations are a skill, not a personality trait. Here is a practical approach CEOs can use to prepare, deliver and follow through.
Why CEOs Avoid Hard Conversations
Most leaders avoid difficult conversations for understandable reasons:
- Loyalty. The person helped build the company, and the conversation feels like a betrayal.
- Fear of fallout. You worry a key person will quit, or the team will lose morale.
- Uncertainty. You are not sure you have all the facts.
- Isolation. There is no one inside the company you can rehearse with.
The cost of avoiding them is real. Your best people notice when poor performance is tolerated. Small issues turn into legal, cultural or financial problems.
Before the Conversation: Prepare
Get clear on your purpose
Write one sentence that states what you need the other person to understand and what outcome you want. If you cannot write it, you are not ready to have the conversation.
Separate facts from stories
List the specific behaviors and results you have observed. “Three of the last four client deliverables were late” is a fact. “You don’t care about clients” is a story. Lead with facts.
Anticipate their reaction
Think about how the person is likely to feel and respond. Understanding their perspective, what researchers call cognitive empathy, helps you stay steady without absorbing their emotions. Our article on cognitive vs emotional empathy explains why that distinction matters for leaders.
Choose the right setting
Private, in person when possible, and not late on a Friday when the person has no one to talk to. Give the conversation enough time.
During the Conversation: A Simple Structure
- Get to the point quickly. Do not bury the message under small talk. “I want to talk about the delays on the Hamilton project, and how we fix them.”
- Share the facts. Describe what you observed and the impact on the business.
- Ask and listen. “How do you see it?” Then listen without interrupting. You may learn something that changes your view.
- Acknowledge emotion. “I can see this is frustrating.” Acknowledging feelings is not the same as agreeing.
- Agree on next steps. End with specific actions, owners and dates.
Phrases That Help
| Instead of | Try |
|---|---|
| “You always miss deadlines.” | “The last three deadlines slipped. Help me understand what happened.” |
| “This isn’t working.” | “The results we agreed on are not happening, and we need to change something.” |
| “Don’t take this personally.” | “I know this is hard to hear, and I want to work through it with you.” |
| “We’ll see how it goes.” | “Let’s meet again on the 15th to review progress.” |
After the Conversation: Follow Through
A difficult conversation is only as good as what happens next. Send a short written summary of what you agreed. Put the follow-up meeting on the calendar. If things improve, say so. If they do not, the next conversation will be clearer because the expectations are on record.
Special Cases CEOs Face
Conversations with partners or family members
When the other person is a co-owner or relative, the business and personal relationship are tangled together. Agree in advance that business decisions will be discussed in a business setting, with clear roles. An outside facilitator or advisory board can help keep the conversation fair.
Delivering bad news to the whole company
Tell people early, tell them what you know and what you do not, and tell them what happens next. Your leadership team should hear first so they can support their teams.
Frequently Asked Questions
What if the person gets angry or cries?
Pause and give them a moment. Acknowledge the emotion, and if needed, offer to continue the next day. Do not change the message to make the emotion go away.
Should HR be in the room?
For conversations about performance improvement plans, discipline or termination, involving HR or legal counsel is often wise. For coaching conversations, one-on-one usually works better.
How can I get better at this?
Practice. Many leaders rehearse with an executive coach or a trusted peer before high-stakes conversations.
Related reading: business strategist vs coach: what is the difference?.
Practice With People Who Have Been There
The CEOs in our peer groups bring their hardest conversations to the table before they have them. Having that kind of sounding board makes the moment itself far easier.
Book a confidential conversation with Fenella Kim. No pitch, no pressure, just a candid talk between leaders.